A modest proposal for a replacement of the A*-C metric

Results day in August was a day of mixed emotions. Our school recorded an impressive leap in the amount of pupils who gained 5 A*-C grades including English and Maths, and many teachers were quite frankly surprised by this improvement. However, such surprise is not necessary when one considers the nefarious means by which schools manipulate their results and record such ‘improvements’.

At the root of this manipulation is the metric used for measuring school success. The ‘five good A*-C grades’ measurement values Cs as much as it values A*s, as schools are measured according to how many pupils gain a grade C or above in five or more subjects. I cannot think how the dim-witted bureaucrat who devised this metric did not realise what the inevitable response in schools would be.

For struggling schools, there is an all-consuming focus during year 11 on achieving C grades. Pupils who are on a C/D borderline are showered with attention, sent on residential study breaks, and given intensive small class teaching. There is an entire cottage industry in training days with titles such as ‘improving school performance: turning Ds into Cs’. Therefore, the educational ethos which has developed due to this short-sighted bureaucratic measurement is one that prizes mediocrity. The metric is actively slanted against recognising high performers gaining As and A*s.

An easy and inexpensive reform could completely do away with this corrupting measurement. Every GCSE grade could be assigned a point score, starting with ‘0 points’ for a U, and going up to ‘8 points’ for an A*. Bright cookies who got ten A*s would score 80 points, whereas midrange pupils with ten Cs would score 40 points. Schools could then be measured on the average points score achieved by all their pupils.

There you have it: an easy and effective way of removing the depressing C worship that takes over our schools every exam term.


~ by goodbyemisterhunter on September 17, 2012.

One Response to “A modest proposal for a replacement of the A*-C metric”

  1. Hi,

    This measure already exists and is published nationally by the DfE – it’s called the Average Points Score (APS). There is another measure which is called the Capped Average Points Score (CAPS) which is better because it only takes the best 8 subjects and therefore stops schools ‘harvesting’ lots of C grades rather than pushing students up to the highest level.

    The only difference to your proposal is that, for some reason, the scoring system is A*=58 points; A = 52 and so on down in increments of 6.

    The reason that this statistic has never taken off in the public perception is that governments of various colours have never openly spoken about it – the official press releases from the DfE are always about 5A*-C inc E&M never about CAPS.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: